Beagle vs Newfoundland: Which Dog Breed Should You Choose?

Choosing between a Beagle and a Newfoundland? Both breeds have unique traits that can fit different lifestyles and family dynamics. Let’s break down their differences to help you decide. (Beagle vs Newfoundland)

This comparison is perfect for families, first-time dog owners, or anyone considering adding a new furry member to their household. You might be wondering which breed is better for your living situation, especially if you have kids or live in an apartment. The Beagle's small size and friendly nature contrast with the Newfoundland's gentle giant demeanor, leading to important decisions based on your family's needs and lifestyle.

Quick verdict

If you’re looking for a small, energetic companion, the Beagle is a great choice, while the Newfoundland is perfect for those who want a calm, loving giant.

Choose beagle if...

Choose the Beagle if you have an active family that enjoys outdoor activities and needs a dog that’s friendly and playful with kids.

Choose newfoundland if...

Opt for the Newfoundland if you prefer a larger, more laid-back dog that excels in loyalty and is great with children, but be prepared for some grooming and space.

Head-to-head comparison

Feature	beagle	newfoundland	Winner
Size	Small (20-30 lbs)	Giant (25-75 lbs)	newfoundland
Energy Level	Moderate (4/5)	Low (3/5)	beagle
Shedding Level	Moderate (3/5)	Moderate (2/5)	newfoundland
Trainability	Moderate (3/5)	Good (4/5)	newfoundland
Kid Friendly	Excellent (5/5)	Good (4/5)	beagle
Monthly Cost	$80 - $150	$100 - $200	beagle
Lifespan	12-15 years	10-14 years	beagle
Grooming Needs	Low (2/5)	Low (2/5)	Equal

Deep dive

Energy Level and Exercise Needs

When comparing Beagle vs Newfoundland, energy levels differ significantly. Beagles are known for their playful, curious nature, requiring regular exercise to stay happy and healthy. They thrive on activities like walks, playtime, and even scent work. Newfoundlands, on the other hand, are more laid-back. While they still need regular exercise, their lower energy means they can be quite content with leisurely strolls and gentle play.

Trainability and Behavior

In terms of trainability, the Newfoundland tends to have an edge. They are eager to please and often pick up commands quickly. Beagles, while intelligent, can be a bit stubborn. This makes training a challenge, especially for first-time owners. If you're looking for a dog that will follow commands reliably, the Newfoundland may be the better choice.

Ownership Costs

Regarding costs, both breeds fall into a similar range, but Beagles might have a slight advantage. Monthly expenses for Beagles typically range from $80 to $150, while Newfoundlands can range from $100 to $200. Additionally, their lifespan suggests fewer vet visits for Beagles, which can further alleviate long-term ownership costs. However, consider that both breeds can be prone to specific health issues, which may incur extra veterinary costs.

Who wins for families with kids?

When it comes to families with kids, the Beagle takes the win. Beagles are friendly, curious, and naturally good with children. Their playful nature makes them great companions for active households, while their size keeps them manageable for little ones.

Who wins for apartments?

In the apartment living scenario, both breeds can adapt, but the Beagle edges out slightly. While both breeds are medium in energy, Beagles have a smaller size and are more flexible in smaller spaces. They do require regular exercise but are generally fine in apartments as long as they get outdoor time.

Who wins for first-time owners?

For first-time dog owners, the Beagle is often the better choice. Their friendly disposition and trainability make them easier to manage. While Newfoundlands are gentle giants, they require more space and can be less forgiving of beginner mistakes.

Who wins for costs?

When considering ownership costs, the Beagle generally wins out. The initial and ongoing expenses for Beagles are typically lower compared to Newfoundlands. Beagles have a lower monthly cost range of $80 to $150, while Newfoundlands often cost between $100 and $200 monthly.

Who wins for energy level?

In terms of energy levels, the Beagle takes the lead. Beagles are known for their playful antics and require more frequent exercise compared to Newfoundlands. If you're looking for a dog that enjoys outdoor play and activities, the Beagle is your winner.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, Beagle or Newfoundland?

Choosing between a Beagle and a Newfoundland depends on your lifestyle and needs. Beagles are small, energetic, and great for active families. Newfoundlands are larger, calmer, and excel as gentle giants, making them suitable for families with space. This answer relates to Beagle vs Newfoundland.

Is Beagle more expensive than Newfoundland?

In general, Beagles may have lower initial costs compared to Newfoundlands. Beagle's first-year expenses range from $1,300 to $2,300, while Newfoundlands typically cost between $1,500 and $2,800. However, monthly care for both breeds is similar.

How do Beagle and Newfoundland energy levels compare?

Beagles are more energetic, rated at 4 out of 5 for energy, while Newfoundlands have a lower energy level of 3. Beagles require more exercise and playtime, making them better suited for active families.

What are the grooming needs of Beagles versus Newfoundlands?

Both breeds have moderate grooming needs, but Beagles require slightly more frequent brushing due to their shedding. Newfoundlands have a thicker coat that may need regular grooming, especially during shedding seasons.

Are Beagles or Newfoundlands better for apartments?

Both breeds can adapt to apartment living, but Beagles may be more suitable for active owners who can provide regular exercise. Newfoundlands are larger and may need more space, so they are better suited for homes with yards.

How do Beagle and Newfoundland health issues differ?

Beagles are prone to obesity and various health issues like hip dysplasia and ear infections. Newfoundlands commonly face hip dysplasia and allergies. It's essential to consider these potential health concerns when choosing a breed.

Which breed is friendlier, Beagle or Newfoundland?

Both breeds are friendly, but Beagles are known for their curiosity and sociability. Newfoundlands are loyal and gentle, making them great companions for children and families.

How do Beagle and Newfoundland trainability compare?

Beagles are moderately trainable, rated 3 out of 5, while Newfoundlands score slightly higher at 4. Beagles can be stubborn due to their hunting background, while Newfoundlands are eager to please, making training easier.