Bernese Mountain Dog vs Mastiff (English Mastiff)

When comparing energy levels, the Bernese Mountain Dog is moderately active. They enjoy daily walks and play but can also relax indoors. In contrast, the English Mastiff is more laid-back and prefers lounging around. This means that if you have a busy lifestyle, the Bernese might be a better fit, while the Mastiff is perfect for those who enjoy a quieter home.

Shedding can be a major consideration for dog owners. The Bernese Mountain Dog has a thick, double coat that sheds heavily during seasonal changes, requiring regular grooming. On the other hand, the English Mastiff has a short, dense coat with moderate shedding. If maintaining a clean home is a priority, the Mastiff may be the better option.

In terms of initial costs, the Bernese Mountain Dog typically costs less to care for in the first year compared to the Mastiff. Bernese owners can expect to spend between $1,800 and $3,200, while Mastiff owners might spend between $2,200 and $4,500. This difference is largely due to the Mastiff's larger size, which results in higher food and vet costs.

When it comes to family-friendly dogs, the Bernese Mountain Dog takes the crown. Known for their gentle and calm demeanor, Bernese are exceptionally good with children. They have a strong protective instinct and are very loyal, making them great companions for families.

While the Mastiff (English Mastiff) is also known for being good with kids, their giant size can be intimidating for smaller children. They are gentle giants but may not be as playful or engaging as the Bernese. For families looking for a friendly, interactive dog, the Bernese Mountain Dog is the better choice.

Neither the Bernese Mountain Dog nor the Mastiff is ideal for apartment living, but the Bernese might have a slight edge. With a lower energy level, the Mastiff tends to be more laid-back, which can be beneficial in a smaller space. However, both breeds need space to move around comfortably.

The Bernese does have some tolerance for being left alone and can adapt better to a smaller environment with proper exercise. For those living in an apartment, the Mastiff may do okay, but the Bernese Mountain Dog is a slightly better fit due to its ability to engage with family activities.

In the battle of costs, the Mastiff is generally more expensive to maintain. Their larger size means higher food and vet costs, ranging from $150 to $350 monthly, compared to the Bernese Mountain Dog's $120 to $250.

Additionally, Mastiffs are prone to more serious health issues, which can lead to higher vet bills. If you’re budget-conscious, the Bernese Mountain Dog offers a more manageable ownership cost in both food and health care, making it the winner for those concerned about expenses.

For first-time dog owners, the Bernese Mountain Dog is the clear winner. They are generally more trainable and forgiving, making them easier to handle for novice owners. Their friendly nature and desire to please can help new pet parents navigate challenges more effectively.

On the other hand, the Mastiff can be stubborn and may require a more experienced handler to train effectively. If you're new to dog ownership, the Bernese Mountain Dog is a much more suitable choice.