DogBreedCompass

German Shepherd vs Great Dane: Key Differences and Considerations

Choosing between a German Shepherd and a Great Dane can be tough. Both breeds are beloved for different reasons, but they come with unique traits and needs. Understanding these differences is key to making the right choice for your home. (German Shepherd vs Great Dane)

This comparison is for potential dog owners who are torn between the German Shepherd and Great Dane. You might be a family looking for a friendly, loyal companion or a busy professional considering space and exercise needs. Perhaps you're interested in how these breeds fit into your lifestyle, whether you have kids, live in an apartment, or have experience with dog training.

Quick verdict

If you want a protective, trainable companion, choose the German Shepherd; for a gentle giant with a friendly demeanor, the Great Dane is ideal.

Choose german shepherd if...

Pick a German Shepherd if you have experience with dogs, need a protective family member, and can provide plenty of exercise and training.

Choose great dane if...

Choose a Great Dane if you prefer a laid-back, kid-friendly dog and have the space for a giant breed, but be prepared for high food costs.

Head-to-head comparison

Featuregerman shepherdgreat daneWinner
SizeLarge (50-90 lbs)Giant (110-175 lbs)great dane
Energy LevelHigh (4/5)Moderate (3/5)german shepherd
Shedding LevelHigh (4/5)Moderate (3/5)great dane
TrainabilityHigh (5/5)Moderate (3/5)german shepherd
Cost (Monthly)$125 - $250$200 - $400german shepherd
Lifespan9-13 years7-10 yearsgerman shepherd
Kid FriendlyGood (4/5)Excellent (5/5)great dane
Apartment SuitableModerate (2/5)Poor (1/5)german shepherd

Deep dive

Energy Levels: German Shepherd vs Great Dane

German Shepherds are known for their high energy and need for regular exercise. This breed thrives on activity and mental stimulation, making them great companions for active families or individuals. In contrast, Great Danes have a more moderate energy level. They enjoy playtime but are also content lounging around the house. This difference can greatly impact your lifestyle and daily routine.

Trainability: Understanding the Differences

When it comes to trainability, German Shepherds lead the pack. They are intelligent and eager to please, making them excellent candidates for obedience training and various dog sports. Great Danes are also trainable, but their independent nature means they may require more patience and consistency. This can be a crucial factor for new dog owners deciding between the two breeds.

Living Conditions: Apartment vs House

For those living in apartments, German Shepherds may be a better fit due to their moderate size and adaptability. They can thrive in smaller spaces if given enough exercise. Great Danes, being larger and less adaptable, typically need more space and are not well-suited for apartment living. If you live in a smaller home, this consideration is essential when choosing between these two breeds.

Who wins for apartments

When it comes to apartment living, the German Shepherd is the better choice. While both breeds are large, the German Shepherd is more adaptable to smaller spaces compared to the Great Dane. GSDs require regular exercise, but they can manage with daily walks and playtime, whereas Great Danes need more room to stretch out and can feel cramped in tight quarters.

Who wins for families with kids

For families with children, the Great Dane takes the lead. Known for their gentle nature, Great Danes are friendly and patient with kids, making them great family pets. German Shepherds, while also good with children, can be more protective and require careful socialization to ensure they are comfortable around younger family members.

Who wins for costs

In terms of ownership costs, the German Shepherd is the more economical option. Monthly expenses for a GSD range from $125 to $250, while a Great Dane can cost between $200 and $400 monthly. Additionally, the first-year costs for a German Shepherd are generally lower, making them a better fit for budget-conscious owners.

Who wins for first-time owners

First-time dog owners may find the Great Dane more manageable. Although both breeds have their challenges, Great Danes are typically more laid-back and require less exercise than German Shepherds. However, it's essential to remember that both breeds need training and socialization, so new owners should be prepared for commitment regardless of their choice.

Who wins for exercise needs

For exercise needs, the German Shepherd is the standout winner. With a higher energy level, GSDs require more regular and intense exercise to stay healthy and happy. Great Danes, while they do need daily activity, are less demanding and can thrive with moderate exercise. If you're an active person looking for a workout buddy, the German Shepherd is your best bet.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, German Shepherd or Great Dane?

Choosing between a German Shepherd and a Great Dane depends on your lifestyle. German Shepherds are active and protective, while Great Danes are gentle giants who love families. If you have kids and want a friendly dog, a Great Dane might be a better fit. This answer relates to German Shepherd vs Great Dane.

Is a German Shepherd more expensive than a Great Dane?

On average, the monthly costs for a German Shepherd range from $125 to $250, while Great Danes can cost between $200 and $400. Therefore, in terms of ongoing costs, a Great Dane is typically more expensive than a German Shepherd.

How do the energy levels of German Shepherds and Great Danes compare?

German Shepherds have a high energy level and require plenty of exercise, while Great Danes have a moderate energy level. If you lead an active lifestyle, a German Shepherd may be a better match for you.

Are German Shepherds suitable for apartment living compared to Great Danes?

German Shepherds are not particularly well-suited for apartments due to their high exercise needs, and Great Danes are even less suitable. Both breeds thrive in homes with ample space and access to outdoor activities.

How do German Shepherds and Great Danes behave with children?

Great Danes are known for being very kid-friendly and gentle, making them great family pets. German Shepherds are also good with children but can be more protective and require proper socialization.

What are the common health issues for German Shepherds and Great Danes?

Both breeds can experience health issues. German Shepherds often suffer from hip and elbow dysplasia, while Great Danes are prone to bloat and heart disease. Regular vet check-ups are essential for both breeds.

What training needs do German Shepherds have compared to Great Danes?

German Shepherds are highly trainable and require consistent, firm training. Great Danes are also trainable but may be less eager to please. Both breeds benefit from early socialization and obedience training.

How do the grooming needs of German Shepherds and Great Danes compare?

German Shepherds have a double coat and require regular grooming, especially during shedding season. Great Danes, with their short coat, have lower grooming needs and are easier to maintain.

Quick answers

View more answers
Living

What is the energy level of a German Shepherd?

German Shepherds have a high energy level and need plenty of exercise.

Living

What is the shedding level of a Great Dane?

Great Danes have a moderate shedding level, requiring minimal grooming.

Training

Are German Shepherds good for first-time owners?

German Shepherds are not the best choice for first-time owners due to their training needs.

Costs

How much does a Great Dane cost per month?

Great Danes generally cost between $200 and $400 per month for food and care.

Health

What is the lifespan of a German Shepherd?

German Shepherds typically live between 9 and 13 years.

Related DogBreedCompass guides

Related guides

Important reminder

This guide is not medical advice. If your dog shows pain, sudden behavior change, or worsening symptoms, consult a licensed veterinarian.

Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only suggest products we believe are helpful for dog owners.

Find Your Perfect Breed

Match your lifestyle to the right dog.

Take quiz

Find your match

Not sure which breed is right for you? Take our 2-minute quiz to find out.

Take the quiz