DogBreedCompass

Pug vs Saint Bernard: Choosing the Right Breed for Your Home

Are you torn between getting a Pug or a Saint Bernard? Both breeds have unique traits that can fit different lifestyles and living situations. (Pug vs Saint Bernard)

This comparison is for potential dog owners who are considering adopting either a Pug or a Saint Bernard. You might be a first-time dog owner, a family with children, or someone living in an apartment. Understanding the differences between these two breeds can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your needs and environment.

Quick verdict

If you want a compact, playful companion, choose a Pug; for a gentle giant that's great with families, go for a Saint Bernard.

Choose pug if...

Choose a Pug if you live in an apartment, prefer a smaller dog, or want a breed that requires moderate exercise and grooming.

Choose saint bernard if...

Opt for a Saint Bernard if you have ample space, want a loyal family dog, and can manage their grooming and exercise needs.

Head-to-head comparison

Featurepugsaint bernardWinner
SizeSmall (12-16 inches, 14-18 lbs)Giant (26-30 inches, 100-200 lbs)saint bernard
Energy LevelLow (2/5)Medium (3/5)saint bernard
TrainabilityModerate (3/5)Good (4/5)saint bernard
Grooming NeedsLow (2/5)Low (2/5)Equal
Kid-FriendlyYes (4/5)Yes (4/5)Equal
Monthly Cost$100-$200$100-$200Equal
Health IssuesHip Dysplasia, Ear InfectionsHip Dysplasia, Ear InfectionsEqual
Lifespan10-14 years10-14 yearsEqual

Deep dive

Size Matters: Pug vs Saint Bernard

When comparing Pugs and Saint Bernards, size is the most obvious difference. Pugs are small, typically weighing between 14 and 18 pounds, making them ideal for apartments and smaller living spaces. In contrast, Saint Bernards can weigh between 100 and 200 pounds and require ample space to move around comfortably, which might not be feasible in smaller homes.

Energy Levels: Finding the Right Fit

Pugs have a low energy level, making them perfect for owners who prefer a more laid-back lifestyle. They enjoy short walks and playtime but are just as happy lounging on the couch. On the other hand, Saint Bernards have a medium energy level, needing regular exercise to stay healthy and happy. This difference can greatly impact your daily routine and lifestyle.

Trainability: Which Breed Learns Better?

Both Pugs and Saint Bernards are friendly and eager to please, but their trainability varies. Pugs can be somewhat stubborn, requiring patience and consistency during training. On the other hand, Saint Bernards tend to be more eager to learn, making them easier to train. This can be a crucial factor for first-time dog owners or families with young children.

Who wins for apartments

When it comes to living in an apartment, the Pug takes the lead. Their small size makes them well-suited for smaller spaces. While both breeds can adapt to apartment life, the Pug's lower exercise needs and moderate energy level mean they can thrive in these environments without needing a large yard.

Who wins for families with kids

For families with children, both the Pug and Saint Bernard are good choices, but the Saint Bernard shines a bit brighter. Their gentle temperament and patience make them excellent companions for kids. While Pugs are also friendly, the Saint Bernard’s larger size can be more reassuring for children during playtime.

Who wins for costs

In terms of ownership costs, both the Pug and Saint Bernard are comparable, typically ranging from $1,500 to $2,800 in the first year. However, the Pug may slightly edge out due to its smaller size, which can lead to lower feeding costs. Thus, if minimizing expenses is a priority, the Pug is a smart choice.

Who wins for first-time owners

When it comes to first-time dog owners, the Pug is often the better option. They are generally easier to train and adapt well to a variety of living situations. While the Saint Bernard is also friendly and trainable, their size can be a bit daunting for new owners who may not be prepared for a giant dog.

Who wins for energy level

For those seeking a lower-energy companion, the Pug is the clear winner. With an energy level of 2, Pugs are content with moderate playtime and short walks. In contrast, the Saint Bernard has a slightly higher energy level of 3, which may require more activity to keep them engaged and happy.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, Pug or Saint Bernard?

Choosing between a Pug and a Saint Bernard depends on your lifestyle. Pugs are smaller and more suited for apartment living, while Saint Bernards need more space due to their size. Both breeds are friendly and good with kids, making them great family pets.

Is Pug more expensive than Saint Bernard?

The costs for both Pugs and Saint Bernards are similar, typically ranging from $100 to $200 monthly for care. However, initial costs may vary depending on the breeder or rescue. Overall, you can expect comparable yearly expenses for both breeds.

What are the energy levels of Pug vs Saint Bernard?

Pugs have a moderate energy level of about 2, making them great for less active families. In contrast, Saint Bernards have a slightly higher energy level of 3. Both breeds enjoy playtime but can adapt to various activity levels.

Can Pugs and Saint Bernards live in apartments?

Both Pugs and Saint Bernards can live in apartments, but Pugs are generally better suited due to their smaller size. However, you should ensure they get enough exercise and mental stimulation, especially for the larger Saint Bernard.

Do Pugs or Saint Bernards shed more?

Both breeds have a moderate shedding level. Pugs may shed slightly less due to their smaller size. Regular grooming can help manage shedding and maintain their coats.

How trainable are Pugs compared to Saint Bernards?

Pugs have a trainability score of 3, while Saint Bernards score a bit higher at 4. Saint Bernards may respond better to training due to their larger size and willingness to please, but both can learn commands with patience.

Are Pugs friendly with kids and other pets?

Yes, Pugs are known to be friendly with kids and other pets, making them great family dogs. Saint Bernards also share this trait, being gentle giants that are good with children and can coexist well with other animals.

What are the common health issues for Pugs and Saint Bernards?

Both breeds can face health issues like hip dysplasia, ear infections, and allergies. Regular vet check-ups and a healthy diet can help mitigate some of these concerns.

Quick answers

View more answers
Living

What is the energy level of Pug vs Saint Bernard?

Pugs have a moderate energy level of 2, while Saint Bernards have a slightly higher energy level of 3.

Living

How does the shedding compare between Pug and Saint Bernard?

Both Pugs and Saint Bernards have a moderate shedding level, requiring regular grooming to manage it.

Living

Are Pugs or Saint Bernards better for families?

Both breeds are friendly and good with kids, making them excellent family pets.

Training

Which breed is more trainable, Pug or Saint Bernard?

Saint Bernards are generally more trainable than Pugs due to their higher willingness to please.

Health

Do Pugs or Saint Bernards live longer?

Both breeds typically have a lifespan of 10 to 14 years, depending on care and genetics.

Related DogBreedCompass guides

Related guides

Important reminder

This guide is not medical advice. If your dog shows pain, sudden behavior change, or worsening symptoms, consult a licensed veterinarian.

Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only suggest products we believe are helpful for dog owners.

Find Your Perfect Breed

Match your lifestyle to the right dog.

Take quiz

Find your match

Not sure which breed is right for you? Take our 2-minute quiz to find out.

Take the quiz