DogBreedCompass

Newfoundland vs Poodle (All Sizes): A Comprehensive Comparison

Choosing between a Newfoundland and a Poodle (All Sizes) can be challenging. Both breeds offer unique traits that cater to different lifestyles and family needs. (Newfoundland vs Poodle (All Sizes))

This comparison is for dog lovers contemplating which breed to welcome into their home. Perhaps you're a family with kids looking for a friendly companion or a busy professional considering a dog that adapts well to apartment living. Understanding the differences in temperament, grooming needs, and overall costs will help you make a more informed decision.

Quick verdict

If you're looking for a loyal family companion, the Newfoundland might be your best bet, while the Poodle offers versatility and lower shedding.

Choose newfoundland if...

Choose a Newfoundland if you have space for a larger dog, want a gentle giant that loves kids, and can manage moderate grooming needs.

Choose poodle general if...

Opt for a Poodle (All Sizes) if you're in an apartment, prefer a hypoallergenic pet with high trainability, and don't mind regular grooming sessions.

Head-to-head comparison

Featurenewfoundlandpoodle generalWinner
SizeGiant (25-75 lbs)Varies (4-70 lbs)poodle general
Energy LevelModerate (3/5)High (4/5)poodle general
SheddingModerate (2/5)Minimal (1/5)poodle general
TrainabilityGood (4/5)Excellent (5/5)poodle general
Cost (Year 1)$1,500 - $2,800$1,500 - $3,500newfoundland
Lifespan10-14 years12-17 yearspoodle general
Apartment SuitabilityModerate (3/5)Good (4/5)poodle general
Grooming NeedsModerate (2/5)High (5/5)newfoundland

Deep dive

Energy Level Comparison

When comparing the energy levels of Newfoundland vs Poodle (All Sizes), Poodles typically have a higher energy level. They require more exercise and mental stimulation to stay happy. Newfoundlands, while still active, are generally more laid-back and enjoy moderate exercise, making them a better fit for less active families.

Shedding and Grooming Needs

Poodles are known for their minimal shedding, which can be a significant advantage for allergy sufferers. Their curly coat requires regular grooming, typically every 4-6 weeks, which can add to the overall cost. Newfoundlands shed more, but they have a less demanding grooming routine, which some owners may prefer.

Trainability and Intelligence

In terms of trainability, Poodles shine due to their intelligence and eagerness to please. They often excel in obedience training and agility sports. Newfoundlands are also trainable but may require more patience; they respond well to gentle, consistent training methods. If you’re a first-time owner, a Poodle might be easier to train.

Who wins for apartments

When it comes to apartment living, the Poodle (All Sizes) takes the lead. With a higher suitability for smaller spaces, Poodles adapt well to limited room, especially in their smaller sizes. Newfoundlands, while gentle giants, may struggle with space constraints due to their size and need for movement.

Who wins for families with kids

Both breeds are known for being kid-friendly, but the Newfoundland edges out slightly as the winner here. Their calm demeanor and protective instincts make them wonderful companions for children. Poodles are also great with kids and are playful, but Newfoundlands tend to have a more laid-back approach that can be reassuring for families.

Who wins for costs

In terms of ownership costs, the Newfoundland generally comes out ahead. While both breeds have similar initial costs, Newfoundlands usually require less grooming than Poodles, which can save on monthly expenses. However, it's essential to consider that Poodles may have higher potential medical costs due to their range of health issues.

Who wins for first-time owners

For first-time dog owners, the Poodle (All Sizes) is the clearer choice. Their trainability and adaptability make them easier to manage for novices. Newfoundlands can be more challenging due to their size and exercise needs, which might overwhelm inexperienced owners.

Who wins for energy levels

When it comes to energy levels, the Poodle (All Sizes) is the winner. With a higher energy rating, Poodles require more exercise and mental stimulation, making them more active companions. Newfoundlands are lower in energy and prefer more relaxed activities, which may not be ideal for very active families.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, Newfoundland or Poodle (All Sizes)?

Choosing between a Newfoundland and a Poodle (All Sizes) depends on your lifestyle. Newfoundlands are gentle giants, great with kids, and require moderate exercise. Poodles are highly intelligent and trainable, making them suitable for active families, but they need more grooming.

Is Newfoundland more expensive than Poodle (All Sizes)?

Both breeds have similar initial costs, ranging from $1,500 to $2,800 for the first year. However, Poodles can be more expensive over time due to higher grooming costs, potentially reaching up to $2,500 annually compared to Newfoundlands at about $1,500.

What are the energy levels of Newfoundland vs Poodle (All Sizes)?

Newfoundlands have a moderate energy level, requiring regular exercise but are generally calm. Poodles, on the other hand, have a higher energy level and need more playtime and mental stimulation to stay happy.

How do Newfoundland and Poodle (All Sizes) compare in shedding?

Newfoundlands shed moderately, while Poodles are known for their minimal shedding due to their curly coat. This makes Poodles a good choice for allergy sufferers or those who prefer less dog hair around the house.

Are Newfoundlands suitable for apartments compared to Poodles?

While Newfoundlands can adapt to apartment living, they do best with space to move around. Poodles, especially the smaller varieties, are more suitable for apartments as they require less space and can thrive in smaller environments.

How trainable are Newfoundlands compared to Poodles?

Poodles are highly trainable due to their intelligence and eagerness to please. Newfoundlands are also trainable but may take a bit longer due to their more laid-back nature.

What health issues are common in Newfoundlands compared to Poodles?

Both breeds share some common health issues like hip dysplasia and ear infections. However, Poodles are more prone to conditions like progressive retinal atrophy and epilepsy, while Newfoundlands are susceptible to heart issues.

Are both breeds kid-friendly?

Yes, both Newfoundlands and Poodles are kid-friendly. Newfoundlands are known for their gentle nature, while Poodles are playful and active, making them great companions for children.

Quick answers

View more answers
Living

What is the energy level of Newfoundland vs Poodle (All Sizes)?

Newfoundlands have moderate energy, while Poodles have a higher energy level requiring more exercise.

Living

How much do Newfoundlands shed compared to Poodles?

Newfoundlands shed moderately, whereas Poodles are minimal shedders, making them better for allergy sufferers.

Costs

Are Newfoundlands more expensive to maintain than Poodles?

Both breeds have similar initial costs, but Poodles may incur higher grooming expenses over time.

Training

Which breed is more trainable: Newfoundland or Poodle?

Poodles are generally more trainable due to their intelligence, while Newfoundlands are a bit more laid-back.

Related DogBreedCompass guides

  • Newfoundland breed guideLearn more about the Newfoundland breed's characteristics and care.
  • Poodle (All Sizes) breed guideExplore the unique traits and grooming needs of Poodles.
  • Newfoundland cost breakdownUnderstand the costs associated with owning a Newfoundland.
  • Training tips for PoodlesDiscover training techniques specifically for Poodles.
  • Common health issues in Newfoundlands and PoodlesRead about potential health issues in both breeds.

Related guides

Important reminder

This guide is not medical advice. If your dog shows pain, sudden behavior change, or worsening symptoms, consult a licensed veterinarian.

Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only suggest products we believe are helpful for dog owners.

Find Your Perfect Breed

Match your lifestyle to the right dog.

Take quiz

Find your match

Not sure which breed is right for you? Take our 2-minute quiz to find out.

Take the quiz