Great Dane vs Saint Bernard: Which Breed is Best for You?

The size of these breeds is a major factor when choosing between a Great Dane and a Saint Bernard. Great Danes can weigh between 110-175 pounds and reach heights of 28-34 inches, making them less suited for smaller living spaces. Conversely, while Saint Bernards are still large, they weigh between 25-75 pounds and can be more flexible in terms of living arrangements, especially in apartments.

Cost is a significant consideration for potential dog owners. Great Danes typically incur higher monthly costs, ranging between $200-$400, primarily due to their large size and dietary needs. In contrast, Saint Bernards have a more manageable monthly cost of $100-$200, making them a more budget-friendly option for families looking to add a furry member.

When it comes to lifespan, the Saint Bernard generally has a longer life expectancy, ranging from 10-14 years, compared to the Great Dane's 7-10 years. Great Danes are prone to several health issues, including bloat and heart disease, which can significantly affect their lifespan. Saint Bernards also face health challenges like hip dysplasia but tend to be overall healthier for longer.

When it comes to apartment living, the Saint Bernard takes the win. While both breeds are giant dogs, the Saint Bernard is generally more adaptable to smaller spaces. Their calm demeanor and lower activity levels make them better suited for life in an apartment, especially if they get regular outdoor exercise.

Families with kids will find the Great Dane to be the better choice. Known for their gentle nature, Great Danes are incredibly kid-friendly and thrive in active households. Their size might seem intimidating, but they're usually patient and loving with children, making them a great family companion.

For those concerned about ownership costs, the Saint Bernard is the clear winner. Monthly expenses for a Saint Bernard typically range from $100 to $200, while Great Danes can push costs up to $400 a month. This difference can significantly impact your budget, especially when considering food and healthcare.

First-time dog owners may find the Saint Bernard more manageable. With a higher trainability rating, they are easier to train and can adapt well to various living situations. Their friendly and loyal nature makes them a good fit for novice pet parents who may need a little extra help.

In terms of energy levels, both breeds are similar, but the Great Dane often has a slight edge. They enjoy moderate exercise and can adapt to a more active lifestyle. However, if you're looking for a dog that’s content with less activity, the Saint Bernard may be a better fit, as they are generally more laid-back.